Nuclear Physics and RadioactivityHardBloom L4

Question

A radioactive sample consists of two distinct species having equal number of atoms initially. The mean life of one species is $\tau$ and that of the other is $5\tau$. The decay products in both cases are stable. A plot is made of the total number of radioactive nuclei as a function of time. Which of the following figures best represents the form of this plot?

Options

A.
B.
C.
D.

Solution

{"given":"Two radioactive species, each with initial number $N_0$. Mean lives: $\\tau_1 = \\tau$ and $\\tau_2 = 5\\tau$. Total number of radioactive nuclei: $$N(t) = N_0\\,e^{-t/\\tau} + N_0\\,e^{-t/5\\tau}$$","key_observation":"Since both species undergo radioactive decay, $N(t)$ is always decreasing. The rate $\\frac{dN}{dt} = -N_0\\left(\\frac{1}{\\tau}e^{-t/\\tau} + \\frac{1}{5\\tau}e^{-t/5\\tau}\\right)$ is always negative, so the total count can never remain constant or increase.","option_analysis":[{"label":"(A)","text":"Graph showing the total number of nuclei remaining constant over time","verdict":"incorrect","explanation":"A constant plot would imply no decay, which contradicts the exponential decay law. $\\frac{dN}{dt}$ is always negative."},{"label":"(B)","text":"Graph showing the total number of nuclei increasing at some point","verdict":"incorrect","explanation":"The total number can never increase since both decay products are stable and no new radioactive nuclei are produced."},{"label":"(C)","text":"Graph showing the total number of nuclei increasing at some point","verdict":"incorrect","explanation":"Same reasoning as (B) — an increase in radioactive nuclei is physically impossible here since all decay products are stable."},{"label":"(D)","text":"Graph showing a continuously and smoothly decreasing curve from $2N_0$ approaching zero","verdict":"correct","explanation":"The total $N(t) = N_0(e^{-t/\\tau} + e^{-t/5\\tau})$ starts at $2N_0$, decreases monotonically, is concave upward (since $\\frac{d^2N}{dt^2} > 0$), and asymptotically approaches zero."}],"answer":"(D)","formula_steps":[]}

Create a free account to view solution

View Solution Free
Topic: Nuclear Physics and Radioactivity·Practice all Nuclear Physics and Radioactivity questions

More Nuclear Physics and Radioactivity Questions